Hindu law is one of the oldest systems of jurisprudence in the world. It is not a static set of rules but a dynamic body of law that has evolved over thousands of years. The sources of Hindu law are traditionally divided into two categories: Ancient Sources and Modern Sources.
1. Ancient Sources
These sources form the foundation of Shastric law and are rooted in religious and philosophical texts.
Shruti (The Vedas): Derived from the word "Shru" (to hear), these are considered the "words of God." There are four Vedas: Rigveda, Yajurveda, Samaveda, and Atharvaveda. While they are the ultimate source, they contain more religious rites than legal rules.
Smritis: Derived from "Smri" (to remember), these are the recollections of Rishis. The Smritis are the first systematic legal texts.
Dharmasutras: (Early period) Written in prose.
Dharmashastras: (Later period) Written in verse (e.g., Manusmriti, Yajnavalkya Smriti, Narada Smriti).
Commentaries (Bhashyas) and Digests (Nibandhas): Since Smritis were often contradictory or archaic, scholars wrote commentaries to interpret them.
This led to the two major schools: Mitakshara (by Vijnaneshwara) and Dayabhaga (by Jimutavahana).
Customs (Achara): Historically, custom was considered superior to written law in practice.
2. Modern Sources
As India moved toward a common law system under British rule and later as a sovereign nation, new sources emerged:
Legislation: This is the most important source today. Acts like the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, have codified and overriden many traditional Shastric rules. Legislation provides uniformity and aligns ancient law with modern constitutional values.
Judicial Precedents: Decisions by the Supreme Court and High Courts act as binding law. Judges interpret ancient texts and statutes to fit contemporary society.
Justice, Equity, and Good Conscience: When there is no specific law or custom to cover a situation, judges apply basic principles of fairness and common sense.
3. The Role of Custom (Achara)
Custom refers to a rule which, through long usage, has obtained the force of law in a particular family, locality, or group.
Essential Attributes of a Valid Custom:
Ancient (Antiquity): It must have existed from time immemorial.
Continuous: It must have been practiced without interruption.
Certain: The custom must be clear and not vague.
Reasonable: It must not be against justice or morality.
Not Opposed to Public Policy: It cannot violate the general welfare of society.
Not Opposed to Statute: Under modern law, a custom cannot override an express provision of an Act (e.g., a custom allowing bigamy is void because the HMA prohibits it).
"Clear Proof of Usage Outweighs the Written Text"
This famous legal maxim was established in the landmark case Collector of Madura v. Moottoo Ramalinga. The Privy Council held that under Hindu law, a clear and well-established custom is so powerful that it overrides the written words of the Smritis.
Even the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, preserves this role; for example, while Section 5 prohibits marriage between Sapindas, Section 5(iv) and (v) allow such marriages if a valid custom permits them.
4. The Contribution of Legislation
Legislation has acted as a "reformer" of Hindu law. It has:
Unified the Law: Removed the differences between Mitakshara and Dayabhaga schools.
Introduced Equality: Granted daughters equal rights in ancestral property (2005 Amendment).
Secularized Marriage: Introduced divorce and prohibited bigamy, moving marriage from a purely indissoluble sacrament to a legal status.
No comments:
Post a Comment